The fit don’t always survive

Publication date
Friday, 20 Apr 2012

With sexual antagonism such as this, it’s sometimes hard to understand how different genes are maintained in the reproductive process

In an international collaboration, researchers from the Research School of Biology and colleagues from Finland and France have shown how genetic variation persists through generations, rather than being bred out in an evolution towards a ‘perfect type’. The researchers carried out a combined field and theoretical study on the breeding behaviour of European bank voles - a small mouse sized rodent common in Europe and Great Britain. 

The research team observed that males which carried the genes for behavioural dominance were more successful at winning mates. However, their gene sharing female siblings were less successful, having smaller litter sizes. In contrast, females which didn’t carry the genes for behavioural dominance had larger litter sizes.

This phenomenon is called sexual antagonism – where a particular gene is beneficial for one sex, but decreases success for the opposite sex. Coauthor and PhD candidate at the Research School of Biology, Jussi Lehtonen, said that the findings show that reproductive success doesn’t run in the family. "With sexual antagonism such as this, it’s sometimes hard to understand how different genes are maintained in the reproductive process, because if the beneficial effect is much stronger in one sex, one would assume that only the gene with best overall success should be maintained," said Lehtonen.

The research found that, although genes that were maladaptive for one sex were to some extent carried through to the next generation by its more successful opposite sex siblings, the disparity in the genes’ effects for the two sexes was so strong that this would be unlikely to maintain genetic variance by itself.

The researchers also found that the dominant gene was only beneficial for males when it was rare in the population, a process known as negative frequency dependence. It is this frequency dependent effect that helped maintain genetic diversity in their study system. "Males with the dominant gene are quite aggressive, so when the gene gets more common in a population, dominant males are more likely to spend their time fighting, and the tame males get an advantage at that point," said Lehtonen.

This research gives a valuable insight into how genetic variance is maintained over generations and how population factors can influence genetic diversity. The researchers’ findings have been published in Science.